Disillusioned with romance, an ambitious New Yorker (Kristen Bell) travels to Rome, where she plucks magic coins from a special fountain. The coins attract an assortment of odd suitors, including a sausage merchant (Danny DeVito), a street magician (Jon Heder) and an artist (Will Arnett) . But, when a persistent reporter (Josh Duhamel) throws his hat in the ring, the woman wonders if his love is the real thing.